8 Comments
User's avatar
Bryan Keith's avatar

A ministry colleague, years ago, joked that the definition of heretic was “anyone who disagrees with my perspective.” Sadly, this has become lived reality these days.

Ray Greene's avatar

My sister on the phone singing praises of trump while actually crying about the lost souls going to hell in America.

I, on the other end, sounding a warning concerning the con man in the highest office, and asking her why the homeless in America aren’t a priority in evangelical churches.

We both believe the Bible and claim Jesus as Lord.

Which one of us is the heretic?

Maybe neither? Maybe both?

Abigail's avatar

So true. I've been thinking along these lines recently. It is so easily for me to shove people on the right and to the left of me into 2-D, binary theological categories, instead of the fully-fleshed, complex people they are. Thanks for putting it so eloquently!

J.W. Rahn's avatar

Excellent article! 💪

Barefoot Hiker's avatar

This is timely. We could all use a far gentler tone in our discussions, whether of our common faith or our different perspectives.

Junior Heresiarch's avatar

This is why I do that work for you and call myself a heretic from the get go.

Hope's avatar

Mmm idk, I feel like context is important here. Calling someone a heretic for not believing in the Trinity, the virgin birth, penal substitutionary atonement, or other tenets of Christian orthodoxy may be a stretch cuz that's their business and that does perpetuate a lot of intrafaith infighting--but if you're calling them a heretic because they're using the Bible to justify slavery, racism, homophobia, transphobia, misogyny, child abuse, etc, then I think that's pretty much justified. That's calling out bad behavior when you see it.

Craig Sefa's avatar

Even historically it seems that who was called heretics was often more tied to power than theology. I am starting to take being called a heretic as a badge of honor, particularly when I look at the lives and attitudes of those making the claims.